Skip to main content

How to Make a Pretty DIY Polymer Clay Shawl Pin and Stick

A lover of handmade jewelry, Donna has been crafting (and wearing) unique pieces of statement jewelry since she can remember.

Handmade polymer clay shawl pin and stick

Handmade polymer clay shawl pin and stick

Wearable Craft: Handmade Shawl Pin

Shawl pins are popular among knitters and are used to hold a shawl in place or decorate a knitted sweater. These pins are made from a variety of materials and come in many styles. But you may be surprised at how easy it is to make your own out of polymer clay from your local craft store!

The internet is full of tutorials on how to make fancy clay designs, but a lot of these require expensive tools, such as pasta makers, and a lot of detail work. My design is easy and accessible for the polymer clay beginner! The only tools needed are some items you already have around the house. This project is quick and perfect for making a pin to go with your favorite shawl or sweater.

Clay for handmade polymer clay shawl pin

Clay for handmade polymer clay shawl pin

Choosing and Working With Polymer Clay

There are a number of brands of polymer clay and most are available at your local craft store. I've only worked with a couple (Sculpey and Fimo). The only advice I can offer is to pick all your clay from one brand. The different brands of clay are not meant to be mixed or used together.

I used Sculpey for my pin. I like Sculpey because it is soft, easy to work with, and comes in many colors. You can also blend the colors together to change the color or make new ones. Just like with paint, if you add blue clay to red clay and knead them together, you can create purple clay.

Ginger Davis Allman has some simple but important tips on her blog about working with polymer clay. These are very helpful if you've never worked with the clay before.

Gather Your Materials

Craft stores sell tools specifically for working with polymer clay, but you don't really need anything fancy. Here's my list of suggested items to use as tools:

  • Poster board or a coated piece of cardboard to use as a work surface, such as the board that comes in a man's shirt when you buy it
  • Plastic knife
  • Pointy tool, such as a wooden skewer or knitting needle (the clay shouldn't damage your needle if you clean it after using it)
  • Thick dowel to use as a rolling pin
  • Various lids from different size jars or other items to use as tracing templates or like cookie cutters

Important: Do not use any items from your kitchen. You should not use your tools for food preparation after using them with your clay.

I used plum, purple, a little bit of blue, and translucent clay.

I used plum, purple, a little bit of blue, and translucent clay.

Step 1: Cut and Make a Sandwich

The first step is to choose your colors. I used plum, purple, a little bit of blue, and translucent clay. Using your knife, cut a thin slice of clay off the long edge of your block. (If you are using the translucent, cut a thicker piece of this color. It tends to disappear if used in thin amounts.) Sandwich your colors together in the order you want them to appear.

Making a handmade shawl pin from polymer clay

Making a handmade shawl pin from polymer clay

Step 2: Cut and Squeeze

Cut your sandwich in half the short way and put your two pieces together in a thicker sandwich. I placed mine together so that the plum was on the outside edge on both sides of my sandwich (see middle photo above). Squeeze your sandwich together with your fingers around the outside edges, blending together the colors around the edge.

Then cut your resulting roll in half, like you were slicing bread. Try to cut it into equal pieces, but it doesn't have to be very neat or clean. Put your two open halves together in a mirror image, like a butterfly. Squeeze the two pieces together so they stick in the middle.


Step 3: Make a Mosaic

Now use your roller (dowel) to smooth out the surface of your clay pancake. Roll it until your clay is uniformly about 1/4 inch thick. Use your fingers to shape the outside edge roughly into whatever shape you want your final pin to be (round, oval, square, etc.).

Now, to mix up the colors more on the surface of your pin (this is optional), cut your pancake into vertical strips.


Mix up these pieces by putting the left-hand piece on the right, turning some pieces upside down, maybe turning some over, so that the lines of color through your clay surface are jostled. Squish around the edges of your clay so this new arrangement of colors sticks together.

Roll over your clay to make a smooth surface and form the final shape of your pin. Make sure the lines of your pieces disappear—you may need to blend them some with your fingers. You should make sure your clay piece is at least three inches in each direction for your finished pin. Your clay should be no thicker than 1/4 inch. To stretch your clay, roll from the center out to the edges in all directions, like you were rolling a pie crust.


Step 4: Shape Your Finished Pin

Once your top surface is smooth and looks the way you want, you can use your fingers to shape your pin, or trace around an object. Jar lids can be used both as a template for tracing or like a cookie cutter by pressing into the clay. For other shapes, try tracing a small food container or cosmetic case (eyeshadow, blush) to get an oval or a more rectangular shape to your pin. Smooth your outside edges with your finger or a small tool for a finished look.

Then use a smaller object to trace and make a hole in the center of your pin. Keep the center piece that you have cut out—you will use this for your stick. When cutting out the center, make sure your hole is at least two inches in one direction and the walls of your "donut" are about 1/2 inch wide. If the walls/edge of your pin are too narrow, it may crack.

After cutting out the center of your pin, this is a good time to stretch your pin (gently) if you want to make it a little bit bigger in size. Then smooth all your surfaces, including the inside edges of the center, with your finger or a tool. Take some time to make sure your pin is smooth and neat. Unfortunately, the baking process tends to bring out any imperfections. Then gently set aside your pin to start working on your stick.


If All Fails, Don't Despair!

If at any point you don't like how your pieces look, don't worry. Take your unbaked pin, break it apart, and roll it into a long coil. Shape your coil into any form you want (circle, oval, teardrop, square, etc.). Join the ends and smooth the seam very carefully. Make a stick and bake them. Now you've made a simple pin you can wear with pride!

Making the stick for your shawl pin

Making the stick for your shawl pin

Step 5: Make the Stick

To begin the stick for your pin, take a small piece of extra clay and roll it into a log that is about two inches long. This stick does not need to be even or pretty.

Take the clay piece you cut out of the center of your pin and cut it into little pieces (see middle photo above). Place these little pieces along the length of your clay stick, both on the front and back. You can save one piece of your pin center to use as a decoration on the top of your stick (optional).

Roll your stick so your little pieces merge onto your starting log in a marbleized color pattern. Roll your stick with your fingers, moving up and down the length. Apply more pressure at one end so it becomes pointy.


Your finished stick should be about 5 1/2 inches to 6 inches in length and no more than 1/4 inch thick at its widest point. Once my stick was shaped, I put my finger on the top wide part to hold it in place and rolled the rest of the stick a bit to twist the colors (optional). Then you can decorate the top of your stick with a ball made from your leftover clay. I made a slanted surface to the top of my stick and pressed a small ball of translucent clay into it as a finishing touch.


Step 6: Bake and Wear!

Bake both clay pieces according to the manufacturer's instructions. I like to use my toaster oven and place my pieces on my oven tray, covered in aluminum foil. After baking, let the pieces cool completely before touching or wearing them.

This shawl pin should only be worn with knitted items that have a loose enough texture to accept the thickness of the stick. Do not force the stick through your fabric. You will damage your material, and you might break your pin.

Handmade polymer clay shawl pin

Handmade polymer clay shawl pin

© 2013 Donna Herron


Donna Herron (author) from USA on August 17, 2015:

Great, Denise! I hope you make a pin you love. Thanks so much for your comments and support!

Denise McGill from Fresno CA on August 17, 2015:

I really love this. I'm going to make one right now. Thanks.

Donna Herron (author) from USA on October 07, 2013:

Hi CraftytotheCore - I'm sure you and your daughter will enjoy working with polymer clay. It's a lot of fun and you can make so many things out of it - beads, barrettes, pins, all types of accessories! Hope you enjoy yourselves! Thanks for stopping by and commenting. I appreciate it!

CraftytotheCore on October 07, 2013:

That is truly awesome! I have never worked with polymer clay. I bought some little pre-made embellishments from other crafters, but never created my own. I am going to show my daughter this. She loves to work with me and she would simply love to learn how to do this.

Donna Herron (author) from USA on June 25, 2013:

Hi Sharkeye11 - I actually tried to make a shawl/hair barrette. The circle backing piece would have to be curved, perhaps baked over the side of something like a soup can. You need to have the curve to have space to gather your hair. I don't have long hair, so I don't know how much curve or space you would need. Also, the clay is not flexible once it is baked. I don't know if a hair clip/barrette would need some flex to it to work. I'd love to hear if you have any luck making a clip that will work for you! Thanks for reading and commenting :)

Jayme Kinsey from Oklahoma on June 24, 2013:

That is very cool! I have to say though that when I first saw the picture I thought it was a hair clip. I had one that looked just like that that was the best thing ever for holding a french twist. I don't wear a shawl (too hot here!) but I might try your tutorial and see if it will work for hair. :)

Donna Herron (author) from USA on June 24, 2013:

Hi Ceres - Thanks for your comments! I was afraid I used too many photos, but I'm glad you enjoyed the hub and found it interesting. Thanks for stopping by :)

Donna Herron (author) from USA on June 24, 2013:

Hi Natashalh - I usually bake my clay longer than what is directed. I think if you are seriously getting into polymer clay work, the experts prescribe that you always use an oven thermometer. Thanks for reading and commenting!

Ceres Schwarz on June 24, 2013:

Creative and interesting hub. The finished polymer clay shawl pin and stick looks really nice. The mixture of the colors really add to its look. The process of making this shawl pin looks pretty complicated but the images and your instructions help make it easier for readers to understand how to do this.

Natasha from Hawaii on June 23, 2013:

Super cool! I've never had much luck with polymer clay, but I think a lot of that is because my oven is funky.

Donna Herron (author) from USA on June 23, 2013:

Hi Sallybea - Polymer clay is great because you can make something as simple or as complicated as you want and still create something amazing :) Hope you have a chance to try some clay! Thanks for your comments!!

Sally Gulbrandsen from Norfolk on June 23, 2013:

Interesting Hub, I have never used this medium in a craft project before. Great instructions and images - might be something I can attempt in the future. Thanks for sharing pearl13agony